Share on Twitter
September 26, 2012
Dish Networks has escalated its offense against a Sprint proposal that it says could severely jeopardize its wireless
plans. The two wireless service providers are fighting over the FCC's proposed rule changes to Dish Network's AWS-4 mobile spectrum,
40 MHz of satellite frequencies it wants to use for a land-based G4 LTE network.
Dish Networks cannot move forward with its LTE service until the FCC changes its regulations on the AWS-4 spectrum, and
is trying to block a Sprint proposal that would shift the band up 5 MHz from 2000-2020 MHz to 2005-2025 MHz.
Sprint wants the FCC to shift the band plan so that adjacent PCS spectrum in the 1915-1920 MHz and 1995-2005 MHz blocks can
be put up for auction, a sale that could benefit Sprint's LTE service.
Sprint has repeatedly said it "values the H block as LTE expansion spectrum" and will bid on it if the FCC puts it on the
auction offer. Sprint currently uses a separate portion of the PCS band for LTE, making the H block particularly advantageous
to the company.
But Dish says that the shift could have a major impact on its ability to launch LTE in a timely manner. In a Monday FCC
filing, Dish Networks accused Sprint of downplaying the seriousness of the band shift and the negative impact in will have on its
For one thing, moving the band up 5 MHz would force the 3 GPP to restart its standards process for the AWS-4 band, Dish
argued, and create significant new interference issues with nearby government and broadcast transmissions, something that the
FCC is very sensitive about, and Dish knows that.
“Restarting this process would significantly delay the expected completion of LTE Advanced specifications for the band
and severely jeopardize Dish’s commercial plans," the company added.
Dish also said that Sprint had greatly exaggerated the readiness of the H block for LTE technology, and was pushing for
unnecessarily stringent emissions limits on its AWS-4 holdings.
“Not only is it unclear whether the H block can ever be used for full-power broadband LTE, but in making the changes, Sprint
proposes that it would sacrifice a substantial amount of AWS-4 spectrum," Dish said.
Sprint has yet to file a rebuttal to Dish Network's remarks, but told the FCC earlier this month that the H block must be
protected for future bidders. As of today, the FCC still hasn't given its opinion in the matter.
“While Sprint continues to support awarding Dish Networks the ability to deploy terrestrial broadband services in its Mobile
Satellite Services (MSS) spectrum, realization of this goal must not come at the cost of idling the valuable H Block spectrum,”
Sprint said, pushing for emission limits on Dish transmissions.
Impairing the H Block would frustrate the principal benefits potential H Block bidders hope to achieve in acquiring the
wireless spectrum in the first place.
As of this morning, the FCC has given no indication when it will finalize its AWS-4 rules. FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski
and Dish Network Chairman Charlie Ergen will speak at PCIA’s conference next week, sparking rumors of a possible announcement.
In other mobile and wireless industry news
Earlier this morning, Sprint CEO Dan Hesse said that he expects the company to become profitable in about two years from now,
ending many years of steep losses origination from its ill-fated merger with its struggling rival Nextel back in 2005.
Hesse's predictions were made in an interview with Bloomberg where he expressed some optimism about Sprint's long-term
prospects, but he nevertheless warned that the turnaround was a long and very slow process.
Between 2007 and 2011, Sprint totaled $41 billion in annual losses, including a $29.4 billion loss five years ago related to a
massive writedown of its Nextel assets.
Hesse said Sprint's network modernization efforts and LTE rollout, along with its gamble on the iPhone, would recompany to
Overall, Sprint is shedding its money-losing Nextel assets, and has been doing so for almost two years already. Its iDEN
network from its Nextel merger is slated to be decommissioned as soon as July 2013, and so far this year it has taken down 9,600
cell phone sites that were part of the aging push-to-talk service.
But all those efforts have a very steep price tag. The company's five-year contract with Apple for the iPhone cost Sprint
no less than $15.5 billion. Together with the expense of its infrastructure upgrades, the company said in 2011 that it would
have to raise up to $7 billion in debt financing to fund its expansion, adding to the company's already considerable debt load.
Additionally, Sprint is currently working to migrate the 4.4 million iDEN customers remaining at the end of June over to
its new CDMA-based network. This new so-called 'PTT service' faces competition from Verizon's own CDMA PTT service, and AT&T is
aggressively courting customers leaving iDEN.
Sprint's iDEN customers have been a source of new subscribers for its competitors for years, Hesse said during the company's
second quarter earnings call. That trend reversed itself last quarter, when Sprint managed to recapture about 60 percent of its
outgoing iDEN subscribers, up from 40 percent in the first quarter.
Those recapture rates are far above Sprint's historic average, which Hesse pegged at a slim 25 percent. Sprint has not been
without missteps since the Nextel merger.
Despite investing billions into its tie-up with Clearwire on its WiMAX network, the venture has largely failed. Sprint is
phasing out its use of WiMAX and will eventually only use Clearwire to supplement its own LTE network.
The company plans to roll out its new LTE network in 100 new cities in the coming months but its deployment is well behind
competitors AT&T and Verizon Wireless.
In other mobile communications news
In its never ending battle with Samsung's copyright violations with the iPhone, Apple is hoping to press its advantage,
asking for a court order on a wider U.S. ban of its products and an additional $707 million in compensation after scoring
a smashing victory over Samsung in August.
For this additional request, Apple went back to the same San Jose, Calif., court that ruled in August that
Samsung's products copied several key elements of the iPhone.
Samsung is seeking a new trial, arguing that there were a number of instructional errors and decisions on evidence that require
The judge ruled that Samsung had infringed on a number of Apple's key patents and awarded it $1.05 billion in compensation.
Following its court victory, Apple sought to ban the products mentioned during the trial. The company is now seeking to extend
that ban to any Samsung products that potentially infringe on its design patents, which could extend to Samsung's current flagship
Galaxy Tab 3.
This legal case was just one of many ongoing trials in the world in a litigation battle that has gone on in multiple courts
and in several countries.
Friday, a court in Germany ruled that Samsung didn't violate an Apple patent related to how the finger reacts to touch
screens. The latest legal developments come as Apple launched the iPhone 5 on Friday, garnering the usual lines and frenzy
for the launch of a new Apple product.
Sales estimates for the iPhone 5 on the first weekend alone have gone as high as 10 million units. Apple and Samsung are
in a tight battle for smartphone supremacy, with Samsung in the lead thanks to the sheer breadth of the many different phones
Samsung again warned that if left to stand, the ruling would hurt U.S. consumers and lead to less choice and higher prices
down the pipeline.
It also cautioned that it would also embolden Apple to take other rivals to court, the company said in a statement. "Indeed, it
is unfortunate that U.S. patent laws can be manipulated to the extent that it actually gives one company a monopoly over rectangles
with rounded corners, or technology that is being improved every day by Samsung and other companies," Samsung added.
Apple has repeatedly said that it was seeking financial compensation appropriate to Samsung's willful use of Apple patents
in its product line, which has caused harm to the iPhone maker.
Samsung has already said it would drag the iPhone 5 into the legal battle, indicating that there is no likely end to the fight
for a while.
In other mobile news
RIM's increasingly unreliable BlackBerry network is down one more time, disconnecting phone and email users in Europe,
the Middle East and Africa, but this doesn't come as a surprise to some. Almost exactly a year go, a week before Apple's co-founder
Steve Jobs past away, RIM's network suffered outages that lasted up to two days in some cases, and not just in Europe and the Middle
East, but in the U.S., Canada and South America as well.
This morning, Research in Motion's service outage started around 9.00 AM. The company says it's only affecting some users
but the mailbox at Vulture Central was filling up with complaints from readers who've experienced the issue so some would
seem to be a significant proportion.
As can be expected, RIM isn't saying what's going on, only promising to get it repaired as quickly as possible and apologizing
for the outage. "We are currently experiencing a BlackBerry service issue impacting some users in Europe, the Middle East & Africa. All
relevant support teams are working to resolve the issue. We apologize to any customers who may be affected," said Waterloo, Ontario-based
Research In Motion.
The more socially-aware BlackBerry users will already know all this-- BlackBerry's Twitter feed and Facebook page have
had notifications about the issue for the last two hours or so.
In other mobile news
We've all heard of the smartphone and the tablet, and now we can welcome the Phablet. A bit larger than the average smartphone,
but smaller than a tablet and equipped with a stylus, the hybrid phablet has emerged as a subset of the mobile device family.
Samsung recently unleashed mobile developers on stylus-driven applications. In April, the company invited app developers
to build stylus-integrated apps using its 'S Pen' software development kit. Voting is still going on, but the top apps will
receive $205,000 in cash and prizes.
To be sure, Samsung’s Galaxy Note, which entered the U.S. market earlier this year, is perhaps the best-known example. The
Android-based device includes a 5.3-inch touch screen and a stylus, which Samsung calls the S Pen.
Also, LG’s Optimus Vu has rolled out a 5-inch Android device that’s equipped with a stylus, which launched in South Korea
in March of this year.
And other mobile players are likely to follow suit, especially now that Samsung’s phablet sales have eclipsed the 5 million
Josh Flood, senior analyst with ABI Research, says he believes phablets compete with 6 to 8-inch tablets and premium smartphones.
In 2011, six to seven inch tablets accounted for about six percent of all tablet shipments, or about 3.7 million units.
Flood expects the bulk of the tablet market to remain in the 9-inch-plus range until about 2017 or so.
So what type of buyer will want a phablet? “Many of the mobile handset vendors and wireless operators believe the initial
typical user will be what they term feature chasers,” explains Flood. “Additionally, users who are less concerned about data
consumption will be prime targets for phablets as well, as they desire a greater Web-browsing experience and better graphics
from sites such as YouTube.”
The phablet’s stylus, coupled with the larger display, will provide the greatest flexibility for mobile app developers, according to
“The stylus is a very important thing that has finally come back to handheld mobile devices,” says Mike Newman, president
of On the Go-WARE, a Los Angeles company that specializes in mobile app development, software training and recruitment.
Overall, styluses were widely used with mobile devices about 10 to 12 years ago, but the rise of the iPhone made them rapidly outdated,
says Newman. He’d like to see the stylus stick around this time-- “It opens up a whole other realm of creativity you can have
with your apps.”
A stylus gives mobile app developers more flexibility and adds an extra feature to look at, says Flood. “Application developers
can now include an extra dimension in their apps, with pressure sensitivity as a key feature of the Samsung S Pen.”
For now, stylus-oriented applications are limited to drawing, sketching and note-taking, says Flood. He points to Graffiti,
WritePad, 7notes, PhatPad and MyScript Memo as examples.
But the stylus presents plenty of opportunities for other app categories as well. For instance, Flood adds that gaming applications
may start using the stylus substantially over the next three to six months.
Share on Twitter
Advertise with us
This article was featured on Business 5.0 and on
Copyright © Wireless Industry News. All rights reserved.